Towards Alternative Criteria for the Validation of Psychological Treatments [Hacia unos Criterios Alternativos para la Validación de los Tratamientos Psicológicos]

Volume 7 Num. 3 - November 2007 - Pages 347-363

Authors:

Francisco Javier Carrascoso López and Sonsoles Valdivia

Abstract:

The Chambless Task Force criteria have become the standard for the research on outcomes of psychological treatments. However they present conceptual weaknesses and do not contemplate the vast complexity of the research and development of new psychological treatments. The current paper presents a critical review of such weaknesses to propose six sets of alternative criteria for the validation of psychological treatments, which are multidimensional and horizontal: Conceptual criteria, connections with basic research, research on processes of change, research on efficacy, research on effectiveness; and research on efficiency. The six sets of criteria emphasize the relation between the development of psychological treatments and the basic research on psychological processes, the research on the processes of change underlying a treatment, and the research on treatment efficacy, effectiveness and efficiency. Finally, future perspectives within our proposal are presented.

Key words:

Change processes, Efficacy, Effectiveness, Efficiency, Treatment validation,

Full Article

English

More articles in this volume

• - El Aprendizaje de Conceptos de Comparación, Seriación y Clasificación en Personas con Retraso Mental [Learning of Comparison, Seriation and Classification Concepts in Children with Mental Disability]
• - Condicionamiento de Lugar en Ratas y Etanol [Place Conditioning in Rats and Ethanol]
• - Analysis of the Efficacy of Different Thought Supression Strategies [Análisis de la Eficacia de Distintas Estrategias de Supresión del Pensamiento]
• - Identificación Organizacional y Ruptura de Contrato Psicológico: sus Influencias sobre la Satisfacción de los Empleados [Organizational Identification and Psychological Contract Breach: its Influence on Employees' Job Satisfaction]
• - Factors that Affect Decision Making: Gender and Age Differences [Factores que Afectan la Toma de Decisiones: Diferencias por Sexo y Edad]
• - Creencias Relacionadas con la Hipertensión y Adherencia a los Diferentes Componentes del Tratamiento [Hypertension Beliefs and Treatment Adherence]
• - Creencias en Salud en Preadolescentes con Diabetes Tipo 1 [Health Beliefs in Type 1 Diabetes Teenagers]