Volume 15 Num. 3 - October 2015
Is Culturally Sensitive Cognitive Behavioral Therapy an Empirically Supported Treatment?: The Case for Hispanics
Volume 15 Num. 3 - October 2015 - Pages 405-421
Lorraine T. Benuto , William O’Donohue
In this paper we reviewed the literature to determine what “culturally sensitive” interventions (whereby “culturally sensitive” was defined as any study that included a specific focus on the cultural group of interest) can be considered well-established, beneficial treatments for use with Hispanic populations. Despite several hundred publications on Hispanics and cultural sensitivity over the past several decades, only 12 peer-reviewed articles that evaluated empirically supported treatments for the mental health disorders most commonly diagnosed among Hispanics were identified. These studies had significant methodological limitations and few employed the “gold standard” designs associated with randomized clinical trials. From this review we concluded that 1) the ratio of non-empirical to experimental publications is quite high; 2) there is evidence that Hispanics may be effectively treated using conventional cognitive behavioral therapy; 3) there is little evidence that cultural adaptations result in consistently improved effect sizes; and 4) cultural adaptations do not show expected homogeneity regarding cultural tailoring, suggesting that the construct of Hispanic culture is poorly understood.
cultural sensitivity, Hispanics, therapy outcome, efficacy
More articles in this volume
- [317-335] Constructing a Self Protected against Shame: The Importance of Warmth and Safeness Memories and Feelings on the Association between Shame Memories and Depression
- [337-347] Relationship between Parental Narcissism and Children’s Mental Vulnerability: Mediation Role of Rearing Style
- [349-359] Focus on Your Breathing: Does Meditation Help Lower Rumination and Depressive Symptoms?
- [361-375] Engagement with School in Students with Special Educational Needs
- [425-431] Differential Reactivity of Attention Biases in Patients with Social Anxiety Disorder
- [433-442] A Multidisciplinary Approach for Patients with Non-specific Chronic Low Back Pain: Study Protocol and Preliminary Findings